10 Comments
User's avatar
You Might Like This's avatar

Awesome detecive work, thanks for sharing this!

Expand full comment
Patrick Abbott's avatar

I love getting down to the actual sources. It's like an old school adventure game.

Expand full comment
T.J. Haines's avatar

I still say aliens donโ€™t exist ๐Ÿ˜Ž

Expand full comment
Patrick Abbott's avatar

Well, you have as much evidence as Padre Pio did for your counter hypothesis. :) The history of the Church discussion over the possibility, and what it *could* mean for the faith *if* aliens were real are fascinating topics though I love to research and discuss

Expand full comment
T.J. Haines's avatar

Oh yeah, totally with you. Then most intriguing component to his claim is that โ€˜they are not fallenโ€™. Iโ€™d ask why he supposes that. But itโ€™s interesting that he considered that (I did too, in my argument) because I think most donโ€™t even consider that question. Itโ€™s an important part of the mystery.

Expand full comment
Patrick Abbott's avatar

It is an interesting question. Maybe he hoped that other creatures would love God more than are fallen ancestors? Interestingly, of the two known spiritual creatures, homo sapiens sapiens and the angelic, both had Falls. All humanity fell and a third of the angels. So unless he had insight which he never stated he had, it is a mystery why he would have thought so.

Expand full comment
KC's avatar

Fantastic research, Patrick! Well done!

Expand full comment
Patrick Abbott's avatar

Thanks. I love deep research.

Expand full comment
Bridget's avatar

> And itโ€™s available for free on the Internet Archive.

*applause*. Every so often I remember to make that site a small donation for the times when I have been looking for a very specific rabbit and they pull it out of their hat.

Expand full comment
Patrick Abbott's avatar

The Internet Archive is a national treasure and should be protected at all cost.

Expand full comment